I want you to understand what it is like to live in Chicago during this time.

Every day my phone buzzes. It is a neighborhood group: four people were kidnapped at the corner drugstore. A friend a mile away sends a Slack message: she was at the scene when masked men assaulted and abducted two people on the street. A plumber working on my pipes is distraught, and I find out that two of his employees were kidnapped that morning. A week later it happens again.

An email arrives. Agents with guns have chased a teacher into the school where she works. They did not have a warrant. They dragged her away, ignoring her and her colleagues’ pleas to show proof of her documentation. That evening I stand a few feet from the parents of Rayito de Sol and listen to them describe, with anguish, how good Ms. Diana was to their children. What it is like to have strangers with guns traumatize your kids. For a teacher to hide a three-year-old child for fear they might be killed. How their relatives will no longer leave the house. I hear the pain and fury in their voices, and I wonder who will be next.

Understand what it is to pray in Chicago. On September 19th, Reverend David Black, lead pastor at First Presbyterian Church of Chicago, was praying outside the ICE detention center in Broadview when a DHS agent shot him in the head with pepper balls. Pepper balls are never supposed to be fired at the head because they can seriously injure, or even kill. “We could hear them laughing as they were shooting us from the roof,” Black recalled. He is not the only member of the clergy ICE has assaulted. Methodist pastor Hannah Kardon was violently arrested on October 17th, and Baptist pastor Michael Woolf was shot with pepper balls on November 1st.

Understand what it is to sleep in Chicago. On the night of September 30th, federal agents rappelled from a Black Hawk helicopter to execute a raid on an apartment building on the South Shore. Roughly three hundred agents deployed flashbangs, busted down doors, and took people indiscriminately. US citizens—some women and children—were grabbed from their beds, marched outside without even a chance to dress, zip-tied, and loaded into vans. Residents returned to find their windows and doors broken and their belongings stolen. Despite the violence of the raid, it appears no criminal charges were filed.

Understand what it is to lead Chicago. On October 3rd, Alderperson Jesse Fuentes asked federal agents to produce a judicial warrant and allow an injured man at the hospital access to an attorney. The plainclothes agents grabbed Fuentes, handcuffed her, and took her outside the building. Her lawsuit is ongoing. On October 21st, Representative Hoan Huynh was going door-to-door to inform businesses of their immigration rights when he was attacked by six armed CBP agents, who boxed in his vehicle and pointed a gun at his face. Huynh says the agents tried to bash open his car window.

Understand what it is to live in Chicago. On October 9th, Judge Ellis issued a temporary restraining order requiring that federal agents refrain from deploying tear gas or shooting civilians without an imminent threat, and requiring two audible warnings. ICE and CBP have flouted these court orders. On October 12th, federal agents shoved an attorney to the ground who tried to help a man being detained in Albany Park. Agents refused to identify themselves or produce a warrant, then deployed tear gas without warning. On October 14th, agents rammed a car on the East Side, then tear-gassed neighbors and police.

On October 23rd, federal agents detained seven people, including two U.S. citizens and an asylum seeker, in Little Village. Two worked for Alderperson Michael Rodriguez: his chief of staff Elianne Bahena, and police district council member Jacqueline Lopez. Again in Little Village, agents tear-gassed and pepper-sprayed protestors, seizing two high school students and a security guard, among others. Alderperson Byron Sigcho-Lopez reported that agents assaulted one of the students, who had blood on his face. On October 24th, agents in Lakeview emerged from unmarked cars, climbed a locked fence to enter a private yard, and kidnapped a construction worker. As neighbors gathered, they deployed four tear gas canisters. That same day, a few blocks away, men with rifles jumped out of SUVs and assaulted a man standing at a bus stop.

“They were beating him,” said neighbor Hannah Safter. “His face was bleeding”.

They returned minutes later and attacked again. A man from the Laugh Factory, a local comedy club, had come outside with his mother and sister. “His mom put her body in between them, and one of the agents kicked her in the face”.

Understand what it is to be a family in Chicago. On October 25th, agents arrested a 70-year-old man and threw a 67-year old woman to the ground in Old Irving Park, then deployed tear gas, disrupting a children’s Halloween parade. One parent spoke to NBC news about her two-year-old child’s response to the gas. The same day, agents deployed tear gas against residents of Avondale.

“Kids dressed in Halloween costumes walking to a parade do not pose an immediate threat to the safety of a law enforcement officer. They just don’t. And you can’t use riot control weapons against them,” Judge Ellis said to Border Patrol chief Gregory Bovino.

Understand how the government speaks about Chicago. On November 3rd, paralegal Dayanne Figueroa, a US citizen, was driving to work when federal agents crashed into her car, drew their guns, and dragged her from the vehicle. Her car was left behind, coffee still in the cup holder, keys still in the car. The Department of Homeland Security blamed her, claiming she “violently resisted arrest, injuring two officers.” You can watch the video for yourself.

“All uses of force have been more than exemplary,” Bovino stated in a recent deposition. He is, as Judge Ellis put it, lying. Bovino personally threw a tear gas canister in Little Village. He claimed in a sworn deposition that he was struck in the head by a rock before throwing the canister, and when videos showed no rock, admitted that he lied about the event. When shown video of himself tackling peaceful protestor Scott Blackburn, Bovino refused to acknowledge that he tackled the man. Instead, he claimed, “That’s not a reportable use of force. The use of force was against me.”

“I find the government’s evidence to be simply not credible,” said Judge Ellis in her November 6th ruling. “The use of force shocks the conscience.” The court’s November 20th opinion provides exhaustive evidence. “The BWC video shows that the protesters were simply standing there when agents first deployed any force,” Ellis writes. “DHS tried to claim protestors threw fireworks at agents… when the helicopter and BWC footage indicates that those explosions were instead agents’ flashbang grenades.” These stories go on and on. “It becomes difficult, if not impossible, to believe almost anything that Defendents represent.”

Understand what it is to be Chicago. To carry a whistle and have the ICIRR hotline in your phone. To wake up from nightmares of shouting militiamen and guns in your face. To rehearse every day how to calmly refuse entry, how to identify a judicial warrant, how to film and narrate an assault. To wake to helicopters buzzing your home, to feel your heart rate spike at the car horns your neighbors use to alert each other to ICE and CBP enforcement. To know that perhaps three thousand of your fellow Chicagoans have been disappeared by the government, but no one really knows for sure. To know that many of those seized were imprisoned a few miles away, as many as a hundred and fifty people in a cell, denied access to food, water, sanitation, and legal representation. To know that many of these agents—masked, without badge numbers or body cams, and refusing to identify themselves—will never face justice. To wonder what they tell their children.

The masked thugs who attack my neighbors, who point guns at elected officials and shoot pastors with pepper balls, who tear-gas neighborhoods, terrify children, and drag teachers and alderpeople away in handcuffs are not unprecedented. We knew this was coming a year ago, when Trump promised mass deportations. We knew it was coming, and seventy-seven million of us voted for it anyway.

This weight presses on me every day. I am flooded with stories. There are so many I cannot remember them all; cannot keep straight who was gassed, beaten, abducted, or shot. I write to leave a record, to stare at the track of the tornado. I write to leave a warning. I write to call for help.

I want you to understand, regardless of your politics, the historical danger of a secret police. What happens when a militia is deployed in our neighborhoods and against our own people. Left unchecked their mandate will grow; the boundaries of acceptable identity and speech will shrink. I want you to think about elections in this future. I want you to understand that every issue you care about—any hope of participatory democracy—is downstream of this.

I want you to understand what it is to love Chicago. To see your neighbors make the heartbreaking choice between showing up for work or staying safe. To march two miles long, calling out: “This is what Chicago sounds like!” To see your representatives put their bodies on the line and their voices in the fight. To form patrols to walk kids safely to school. To join rapid-response networks to document and alert your neighbors to immigration attacks. For mutual aid networks to deliver groceries and buy out street vendors so they can go home safe. To see your local journalists take the federal government to court. To talk to neighbor after neighbor, friend after friend, and hear yes, yes, it’s all hands on deck.

I want you to understand Chicago.

This essay has been building—eating at me, really—for the last two months. My thanks to all the friends, family, neighbors and colleagues who have talked with me about ICE and CBP. In particular, I want to acknowledge the families of Rayito de Sol—parents like Maria Guzman and Tara Goodarzi, whose powerful speeches have been lodged in my chest. Also the members of One Northside, Aldermen Vasquez and Martin, Senator Simmons, and everyone who spoke at the rally Wednesday. Your call to “tell the story” caught me, and I hope I have done some small part of that work here.

I was particularly moved by Kelly Hayes’ In Chicago, We Run Toward Danger Together and Dan Sinker’s What I Need You To Understand, which inspired the core motif of this essay. His follow-up Ghosts in the Graveyard is also worth your time. Cam’s On Repacking Your Unpacked Funeral Clothes breaks my heart. Laurie Merrell’s Dispatch from Occupied Chicago is a lucid, reflective piece which mirrors my own feelings.

ICE and CBP affect us all: south, east, north and west; city and suburb. In particular, ICE has hit Little Village, a predominantly Latino neighborhood on the Southwest Side, hard in recent weeks. Marginalized communities especially deserve our focus and care.

You can donate your time and money to organizations like ICIRR, which connects immigrants and refugees with legal aid and social services. I also suggest a donation to the non-profit Block Club Chicago or Chicago Sun-Times, both of whom have been doing exceptional local journalism in this dark time. Without their reporting, this would have been impossible.

Aphyr on

As an aside, one of the horrifying things I discovered while writing this piece was this site called factually.co, which ranks high in search engines and uses Large Language Models to create fake “fact checking” articles. They’re running multiple articles pretending Rev. Black wasn’t shot with pepper balls at Broadview, which, to be clear, is definitely a thing that happened.

Aphyr
Ed

Went to check out “factually.co” and asked it to rate itself for bias. I mistakenly typed in “factually.io” and it basically said no evidence that it creates fake “fact checking”. Further it stated there are many sites that look like it and could be mistaken naming “factually.co” as one of these sites.

ray mckenzie
ray mckenzie on

Thank you for this powerful statement. I will share with my community. you have captured exactly what it is like living here now.

NM

Thanks for writing this. Anyone who has claimed to be for freedom should abhor this.

It should be obvious to anyone this is a secret police with no oversight. Even if you believe in deportation this isn’t the way to do it.

If this apparatus can be pointed to one group of people nothing stops it from being pointed to anyone else. A bureaucracy entrenched with a secret police is seldom overcome.

kpossibles
kpossibles on

Thank you for sharing! I didn’t realize how bad it is for Chicagoans right now, they’re in a warzone with ICE daily and the conditions of Broadview ICE Facility are holocaust level internment camp quality.

You think it’s not coming for you in your “safe” neighborhood, but it’s the future right now as ICE invades at every mundane opportunity and with government workers not getting paid leading up to the holiday season while the president builds a guilded ballroom and the Republicans keep the government closed…

Diego
Diego on

They also killed a man! Silverio Villegas-Gonzalez was killed in his Franklin Park neighborhood after masked federal agents ambushed him as he was driving and when he attempted to flee they shot him. Then they fed local media a narrative about their officers being “dragged” by his vehicle when surveillance footage proved that to be false but local media ran with their official statement without getting any witness testimonies. It was only days after when the surveillance footage came out and everyone had already moved on. He was a father of two and his death was justified as an “illegal with a history of reckless driving” when in reality he had a speeding ticket over a decade ago. We cant forget him.

Sara Brown
Sara Brown on

Kyle, I cannot thank you enough for your words. You have so eloquently put into the record what so many of us in Chicago are feeling. We desperately seek to make others understand what is happening in our city, and your post builds a bridge for us to do that.

Coreena
Coreena on

Thanks for sharing Kyle. I wrote something similar last week for my family outside of the city as well. I just posted it to Substack here: https://grape390fluffy.substack.com/p/to-my-family-in-the-midwest

We need more folks like us sharing the stories of the atrocities happening here in the city, hopefully sooner rather than later we won’t be in our own bubble fighting back against this violent incursion. Until then, we keep us safe.

Diana Ellefson

I live on the California coast, and while I was peripherally aware of this happening, the sheer amount and intensity of these events I was not aware of. Thank you for sharing your truth; it really underscores just how fallible any form of centralized news really is in the modern day, especially when compared to the veracity of direct local sources.

Meryem
Meryem on

Hello, from the UK. I used to live in Chicago for a very short time, I loved it very much. I’m so sorry this happening. The prison stories Ive read and heard remind me of my Dad’s description of the early days of the ba’ath prisons. I’m glad to see you all fighting back and hope you succeed. All the best.

Michael S.
Michael S. on

I currently live in Texas, where the entirety of my family lives, with my wife and young child. But I was born in Chicago. I met my wife there. I love it more than any other place I have lived. I can’t express accurately the fury I feel knowing that Texas CBP and ICE tactics (if not personnel, I don’t know, except that I recently was served a disgusting ad attempting to “inspire” me to join ICE), and now the national guard from our state are being used to terrorize. I am essentially incapable of making that sentence make sense because it is so despicable and stupid and maddening. I’m sorry. None of this makes sense, while it is also simultaneously completely boringly predictable and obvious. I just… I just want to say I’m sorry. Thank you for putting all of this together. I long to go home. I miss Chicago so much.

Jake
Jake on

Apparently this is blocked by the UK Online Safety Act?! I have no idea why. Anyway, everybody’s got a VPN these days so up yours Starmer.

Steve Rauworth
Steve Rauworth on

You are grasping at straws. With Democrats and Republicans the choice is negligible, and democracy has been long gone for decades.

Post a Comment

Comments are manually approved. Links have nofollow. Seriously, spammers, give it a rest.

Please avoid writing anything here unless you're a computer. This is also a trap:

Supports Github-flavored Markdown, including [links](http://foo.com/), *emphasis*, _underline_, `code`, and > blockquotes. Use ```clj on its own line to start an (e.g.) Clojure code block, and ``` to end the block.